Answer to Question #9093 Submitted to "Ask the Experts"
The following question was answered by an expert in the appropriate field:
Is it important to measure the element correction coefficients (ECC) for each TLD?
Regarding your first question, the responses of TLDs depend on the physical characteristics of the TLDs, such as thickness and atomic composition, as well as the physical characteristics of the photon radiation field, such as effective photon energy, field size, directionality, and contamination with secondary electrons. As a consequence of such factors, the TLD response (i.e., surface dose per unit TL output) to relatively high-energy photons, such as those from 60Co, may be noticeably different from the response from lower-energy radiation from x-ray machines. Therefore, it is preferable to carry out your calibrations of the TLDs to be used for the entrance surface dose (ESD) measurements using beam qualities similar to those to be used in the patient studies. Typically an appropriate ionization chamber would be used to establish the dose (rates) used in the TLD calibrations for the beam qualities being used.Concerning your second question, unless you have already gone through a process of preselecting TLDs that all exhibit responses within acceptable levels of variability for the intended measurements, you should determine and apply the respective element correction coefficients (ECC) for the TLDs to be used in the measurements.
Good luck in your measurements.
George Chabot, PhD, CHP